At a Glance: Our Top 5 Best Indestructible Dog Toys from the 10 Total Reviewed
- KONG Extreme Dog Toy
- KONG Wubba Dog Toy
- Jolly Pets Romp-n-Roll Ball
- Multipet Nuts for Knots Heavy Duty Rope Toy
- Goughnuts - Original Dog Chew Ring
Note: The links above take you to more information, current prices and customer reviews on Chewy.
Labrador Retrievers – who doesn’t love them? As one of the most rewarding dog breeds in terms of their loyalty, love and playfulness, Labs are undoubtedly the most beloved of companions.
However, if there is a downside to owning a Lab, it’s the continual and vigorous chewing of anything that isn’t nailed to the floor!
As a retrieving breed initially bred to retrieve items in their mouths, labs have a predisposition to carry objects around and chew on them. This is very much an innate characteristic of Labs.
To help prevent destructive chewing, your best bet is to invest in some high-quality, durable toys that they can chew on instead.
This isn’t necessarily as easy as it sounds. Labs are often such vigorous power chewers that they can destroy your run-of-the-mill chew toys within minutes, even those that market themselves as "indestructible dog toys".
We’ll guide you through exactly what you should look for in suitable dog chew toys that can withstand even the most enthusiastic of chewers.
Read on to discover both how to choose and our recommendations for the best, toughest dog toys suitable for heavy chewers.
Contents & Quick Navigation
First Things First: Safety is Key
Although durability and the ‘fun factor’ are obviously important, safety is paramount when it comes to choosing toys – you don’t want your Lab ingesting broken pieces of toy and causing themselves internal damage.
So, what does safety mean when it comes to chew toys for your Lab?
Toughness is obviously important, so it stays intact while receiving a hammering from your Lab, but it also shouldn’t be too hard and put too much pressure on your dog’s teeth either. Compromise is everything!
Also important is the chew toy’s material composition. Always opt for non-toxic materials as the toy will be spending a good amount of time in your dog’s mouth.
Obviously, we want to avoid swallowing chunks of toy as much as possible, but if they are going to have pieces floating through their digestive system, the toy should be made of non-toxic materials.
How to Best Provide Toys With Your Dog's Safety In Mind
Don’t try and second-guess your dog’s power to destroy when it comes to choosing the best toys for them. That potent mix of boredom, willpower and determination in a Labrador can be destructive so make sure the toys you decide on are more than strong enough to withstand heavy chewing.
As always, it’s imperative to keep an eye on your canine companion as they chew to ensure no real damage — to the toy or your pup — is going down.
Small parts dislocating from the toy or a seemingly shrinking size should make you put the toy straight in the bin — your dog should not be allowed to ingest parts of their toys.
Indestructible? Don’t Count On It
Huge numbers of toys are touted as ‘indestructible’ nowadays and it’s easy to fall for the persuasive sales rhetoric.
Chances are, however, it isn’t indestructible and may even be demolished within mere minutes of meeting your Lab.
It’s best to take the indestructible moniker with a pinch of salt, and buy those on the advice of others who can attest to their toughness.
Toys to Avoid For a Heavy Chewer
Avoid Plush and Stuffed Toys
Make sure that you avoid stuffed toys or those made of a plush material too.
Yes, they’re certainly cute, and often very cheap, but there’s a reason for this – they’ll be eaten for breakfast (hopefully not literally!) by a vigorously chewing Lab.
Their durability is close to non-existent if you have a strong chewer.
From a safety perspective too, plush toys are a no-no as an aggressive chewer can easily swallow the stuffing.
Tread with even more caution with squeaky toys — they are a clear choking hazard if the toys are pulled apart.
Vinyl and Latex Don’t Make the Grade Either
Though vinyl is a little tougher than latex, we wouldn’t consider either material tough enough to withstand Labs who chew hard.
They, too, often come stuffed with squeakers so if your Lab is chewing on one, watch carefully that it doesn’t come free from the toy.
So What Should Dog Toys For Heavy Chewers Be Made Of?
The Top Pick is Hard Rubber Chew Toys
Although earlier we warned against falling for the ‘indestructible’ sales pitch, you can rest assured that genuinely hard rubber toys are the closest you can get!
Indestructible chew toys don't exist, every toys life will come to an end, but some can last many months and quality hard rubber toys are easily the best candidates, being the most durable toys on the market.
You may have already come across the Kong brand? Although a little more expensive than lower quality toys, they are one of the most trusted brands on the market for their safe and durable products and also have a huge product selection to choose from.
You’re sure to be able to find the perfect fit for your pup!
Strong, Fibrous Rope Style Toys
Rope-style chew toys are a good bet, especially from a durability point of view.
Their fibrous material is tested and proven to be strong enough to withstand vigorous chewing, while also being incredibly good for cleaning your dogs teeth.
And, good news for busy owners, they’re incredibly easy to wash which is important because many dog toys end up extremely smelly after days or more of being subjected to dog slobber and being thrown around outside.
Look out for cotton rope toys that are almost always exceptionally thick, with dense threads, hinting that they might be indestructible doy toys, or come pretty close.
If you’re worrying about your Lab swallowing a few loose threads, don’t lose sleep over it as they will easily 'pass through' if swallowed.
Quality Costs But is the Best Choice
The temptation to opt for cheaper plush or vinyl toys is understandable, but remember that from a safety and durability angle, they simply don’t make the grade against the superior hard rubber toys.
It’s a false economy to continually buy cheaper toys for dedicated chewers and much more financially prudent to invest in a more expensive, yet more durable and safe product like the hard rubber toys.
We’re talking here about toys that will stand the test of time over a number of months and years, rather than being destroyed within minutes or hours of bringing them home from the pet store.
A single high quality toy that lasts a year is so much better — and cheaper — than buying a $5 toy every month that only lasts a day or two.
Quality costs more — but saves in the long run!
Our Pick of 10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys For Aggressive Chewers
We know that it’s hard to find the perfect dog chew toys for your vigorously chewing Lab so we’ve put together a list of the top ten best toys for strong chewers that we believe are the crème de la crème of the market and sure to keep both you and your dog happy.
The Original (and Still the Best) Tough Dog Toys from Kong
Undoubtedly the market leaders, Kong toys were invented decades back in response to the founder’s German Shepherd needing a tough toy to keep him entertained.
The original "indestructible dog toy" brand, Kongs are super tough and ideal for aggressive chewers. And dogs love to chew them
We love that there’s such a huge variety of different toys on offer in the Kong range – you’ll certainly be able to find something perfect for your Lab. Many of them can even be stuffed with treats for some added fun!
Here is our top 5 picks of battle tested, long-lasting tough Kong Toy range:
Kong Extreme Dog Toy - Ultra-strong, Ultra-Durable
Touted as the world’s strongest chew toy, the Extreme is perfect for the dog who continues to amaze you with how quickly they can destroy.
It’s universally popular with chewers and is used even by police, drug enforcement and military K-9 teams, as well as the Schutzhund and AKC competition trainers.
Recommendations don’t come much higher than that!
Made using carbon Black Ultra-Flex™, the Extreme is puncture-resistant and comes close to being an indestructible dog toy.
It’s non-toxic too and can even be stuffed with treats, which is guaranteed to keep your heavy chewer occupied, stave off boredom and ease any separation anxiety they may suffer from. For this reason, the Kong is also recommended for owners about to start crate training with their dogs.
The Extreme also doubles up as an interactive toy to help you get involved in playtime. It has an unpredictable bounce on it due to its undulating curved design, which is perfect for games of fetch with playful pups.
Kong Wobbler Toy - Tough AND Mentally Stimulating
Living up to its name, the Wobbler toy is a fantastic plaything for your Lab as they try to control it and stop it wobbling, falling over and rolling away from them.
Primarily a food dispenser, the Wobbler can be stuffed with your Lab’s kibble or favorite treat and occupy your dog for hours on end.
This means it’s a great toy to use with dogs that eat their food too quickly when it’s set out in front of them in a bowl – the challenge of retrieving their food from the Wobbler will be enough to get them to slow down and savor.
As always with Kong toys, durability and toughness is guaranteed with the US-made Wobbler.
The real stand-out feature, however, is the fact your dog will be mentally and physically stimulated with the effort needed to retrieve the food and treats so boredom and destructive chewing will seem like a lifetime away.
As an added bonus, the Wobbler is dishwasher safe and also has an easy twist off dispenser – just because your Lab may have a challenge getting the food out shouldn’t mean you have a challenge getting it in!
Kong Wubba Toy - Tough Toy For Fetch and Tug
Moving away from the more traditional dog chew toys for a moment, here we have the perfect interactive toy for frolicking in the park with your Lab.
The Wubba is a ‘tug-and-toss’ toy, whereby you toss it, your pup chases and catches it, fetches it to you when you can then also use it for a game of tug.
It’s comprised of two balls – one of which is a squeaker and the other a tennis ball – and some strong fabric ‘legs’ which your pup will adore pulling and chewing on.
Durability and toughness is key as always, so the balls are covered in super tough nylon while the fabric legs are equally heavy duty.
There’s a variety of colors and sizes available and even an option of plush fabric, which may be more appropriate for lighter chewers.
Remember that it’s always best to supervise your Lab when they’re chewing on toys, and especially if there are balls inside which they want to retrieve.
Kong Dog Toys Goodie Bone - Extreme Durability
Much like the original Extreme toy, the Extreme Goodie Bone is incredibly durable and tough, therefore perfect for withstanding dog's teeth.
Shaped like a bone and made of super strong natural rubber, this power chewer toy can also be stuffed with treats to keep a dog's mind busy, trying to work the treats out.
This will ease boredom and stave off destructive chewing in your Lab as well as easing any separation anxiety they may suffer from.
Made in the US of non-toxic materials, the Extreme Goodie Bone is also puncture resistant.
One of the most interesting features of the toy is the patented ‘Goodie Grippers’ to be found at each end of the bone where you can stuff the toy with treats.
The ‘Goodie Grippers’ make it harder for your dog to retrieve the food, which serves to increase the effort, both mental and physical, of your dog as they go to town on the toy.
You’re sure to return home to a tired, yet satisfied dog!
Kong Squeezz Toy - Strong Squeaky Chew and Throw Stick
What dog doesn’t love squeaky toys?
Earlier we warned against toys with squeakers as they can become choking hazards if a dog rips them apart.
Thankfully, the chew toys from this band are tough enough to withstand the most aggressive of chewers and the Squeez Stick, in particular, protects and recesses its squeaker very well.
More of an interactive toy than a standard chew toy you would leave your Lab at home alone with, the Squeez Stick has enough features to be a truly versatile toy.
Made of non-toxic, thermo-plastic rubber, it’s the perfect compromise for your Lab of chewy and durable while also able to bounce unpredictably — and it floats on water too! This guarantees hours of fun, whether you’re inside or outside, on dry land or near water.
The Squeezz toys come in a variety of shapes, sizes and colors so you have plenty of options to find the perfect one for your Lab.
The Best Indestructible Dog Balls for Strong Chewers
We'd say these are the best balls on the market that are tough enough to withstand heavy chewing, while also being a super fun toy for your Lab to get their teeth into, literally!
Although some of the following aren't strictly "balls" — more like "balls with a twist" — have a spherical shape and serve the same purpose, entertaining your dog exactly the same way.
Tennis balls, footballs — they're just too easily destroyed and the costs soon mount up. But the following will last most dogs many months while saving you a pretty penny.
An especially sturdy ball, the 'Jolly' brand was initially started up to create ball toys for horses so it has a proven track record of creating products that stand up against strong teeth and hard chewing.
After discovering how popular the balls were with heavy-chewing dog owners, a little tinkering helped adapt them to dogs’ wants and needs and they’ve been appreciated by dogs and their owners ever since.
The Jolly Ball with Rope is designed to be kicked, tugged, thrown, carried and launched, all of which equals a great ball toy for playing with outside!
It won’t deflate if your dog does puncture it and it also floats, which is ideal for keen swimmers.
Made of non-toxic Polyethylene plastic – safe for both you and your Lab – and sturdy rope for ‘tug and toss’ games, this toy is heavy duty and durable.
The Jolly Pet Balls are available in a variety of sizes and bright colors so you’re sure to find the perfect fit for your pup.
As we discussed earlier, rope toys are perfect for big chewers due to their intense durability and safety-conscious material composition.
This Nuts for Knots toy is just as tough and substantial as it looks and promises superior durability to other rope ball toys on the market.
It has an impressively sturdy handle too so you can get involved in some seriously interactive games of tug of war with your dog.
Perfect for large dogs like Labs, this Nuts for Knots Heavy Duty Toy is approximately the size of a shot put so is sure to keep your pup occupied for a serious amount of time.
The clue is in the name with this ball toy – your heavy-chewing Lab is not going to have an easy time destroying this virtually indestructible piece of equipment.
Made in the US by 'West Paw Design' with non-toxic, environmentally friendly and recyclable material, this ball is super tough and ideal for the most destructive of chewers.
The manufacturers are so sure of it's durability that it comes with a 100% guarantee.
Ideally shaped for an unpredictable roll or bounce, this toy is great for interactive throwing and rolling games. It also fits into the Chuckit Ball Thrower to really exercise your dog.
The bright colors also make it stand out and easy to find when thrown on any surface.
This ball is bound to be a hit with any pup.
The US made Orbee-Tuff SnowBall is incredibly tough and durable; so much so that Planet Dog are prepared to 100% guarantee its toughness “any time, every time”.
While you’ll be delighted at how long it lasts, your Lab will love the ball’s captivating mint aroma and rough textured surface that makes chewing and playing with this toy a joy.
This strong chew toy has other features that make it the perfect interactive play ball, such as its ability to bounce and float, for Labs that love to fetch and chew hard.
Hollow on the inside, the ball has two small ventilation holes on the side that allow the ball to squish down once it’s bitten on and then bounce back into position once it’s been released so there’s no need to worry about your Lab wearing their teeth down on hard plastic.
OK, it's not a ball, but made in the US by mechanical and polymer engineers, this GoughNuts toy is an ideal throw toy for the powerful jaws of aggressive chewers.
So confident are the inventors in the strength of their product that they guarantee the indestructibility of the toy and are willing to replace it if your dog manages to chew through the tough outer layer.
GoughNuts have created a safety system within their product line whereby if your dog is chewing hard on the black colored outer material, that means they can continue to ‘GoughNuts’ safely, but if they manage to chew through the black to the inner red colored material, the toy should be taken away and replaced
And if your dog does chew through to the red layer, GoughNuts will replace the toy free of charge!
Shaped like a ring donut, this toy will be a firm favorite with your Lab who’ll love chasing after it, picking it up and carrying it around in their mouth.
The toy also floats so is a fun addition to your play routine if your pup is a keen swimmer.
Hopefully, you’re now equipped with the knowledge and recommendations to help you choose the perfect toy for your Lab who chews hard.
Remember to avoid plush, stuffed toys as well as vinyl or latex – these materials simply don’t make the grade against heavy chewers.
It’s cost efficient and safer to start thinking of a chew toy as an investment for a number of months or years so focus on quality materials and fun features that your Lab can’t help but love.
You can’t go wrong with hard rubber and sturdy cotton rope and, if in doubt, always opt for the ultra-durable Kong brand!
Product image credits: ©Chewy.com
Please be aware this page contains affiliate links and Labrador Training HQ receives a small commission if you make any purchases through any such links. This has absolutely no effect on the eventual price that you pay and we are very grateful for your support.
Save this to Pinterest:
This post may contain affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
Top Picks For Our Dogs
- BEST DOG FOOD
We Like: The Farmer’s Dog - We’re feeding all of our dogs fresh dog food. It’s not cheap, but Raven loves it! Get 50% off your first order.
- BEST PUPPY TOY
We Like: Snuggle Puppy w/ Heart Beat & Heat Pack - Perfect for new puppies. We get all of our Service Dog pups a Snuggle Puppy.
- BEST CHEW TOY
We Like: KONG Extreme - Great toy for heavy chewers like our Labrador Retrievers.
For more of our favorites check out all of our Dog Product Reviews.